After the exhausting work of brain tanning—the scraping, the wringing, the breaking—there's one final step that transforms soft buckskin into something truly remarkable: smoking. This ancient technique doesn't just add that distinctive golden-brown color and rich, earthy aroma. It fundamentally changes the hide's chemistry, making it washable, water-resistant, and incredibly durable.
Without smoking, a brain-tanned hide will stiffen when it gets wet, requiring you to re-soften it every single time. But with proper smoking, you create a hide that can be washed, worn in the rain, and still remain soft and supple. The smoke seals the fibers, and in doing so, seals your work.
Why Smoking Matters
Waterproofing
Smoke particles coat each fiber, preventing water from penetrating and causing the hide to stiffen.
Preservation
The tannins and phenols in smoke act as natural preservatives, protecting against rot and insects.
Color & Character
Smoking gives the hide its beautiful golden to deep brown color and that unmistakable campfire scent.
Washability
A properly smoked hide can be washed and will dry soft without needing to be re-broken.
Choosing Your Wood
The type of wood you use matters. You want punky, rotten wood—not fresh green wood. Punky wood smolders slowly and produces thick, cool smoke without flames. Fresh wood burns too hot and can scorch your hide.
Best Woods
- •Willow: Traditional favorite, mild smoke, beautiful color
- •Cottonwood: Soft, punky, easy to find
- •Alder: Cool smoke, even color
- •Aspen: Light, clean smoke
- •Birch: Aromatic, good penetration
Avoid These
- •Pine/Conifers: Too much resin, can make hide sticky
- •Cedar: Oils can affect hide quality
- •Treated lumber: Toxic chemicals
- •Fresh green wood: Burns too hot
Look for dead branches that have been on the ground for a year or more. They should be soft enough to break apart with your hands. If you can peel the bark off easily and the wood crumbles, you've found the right stuff.
Setting Up Your Smoke
The Smoke Pit Method
This is the traditional approach used for centuries. You'll need a small pit or hole in the ground, about 12-18 inches deep and 12 inches wide.
- 1.Dig your pit: Choose a spot away from wind and flammable materials.
- 2.Start a small fire: Use dry kindling to get hot coals going.
- 3.Add punky wood: Once you have coals, pile on your rotten wood. It should smolder, not flame.
- 4.Create your smoke chamber: Sew your hide into a tube or bag shape, leaving one end open to place over the pit.
- 5.Suspend the hide: Use stakes or a tripod to hold the hide over the pit, creating a smoke tent.
The Barrel Method
A metal barrel with the bottom cut out works great for controlled smoking.
- 1.Prepare the barrel: Cut out the bottom and drill some air holes near the base.
- 2.Build your fire: Start coals in a fire pit or metal pan beneath where the barrel will sit.
- 3.Add wood and barrel: Place punky wood on the coals, then set the barrel over it.
- 4.Hang the hide: Drape your sewn hide bag over the top of the barrel, or hang it inside using wire.
"The smoke doesn't just color the hide—it locks in all the work you've done. It's the final handshake between you and the animal."
— Traditional Tanner's Wisdom
The Smoking Process
Preparing the Hide
Before smoking, your hide should be completely dry and soft. If it's stiff anywhere, break it soft again. Any stiff spots won't absorb smoke properly.
Sew the hide into a bag or tube shape using sinew, artificial sinew, or strong thread. You want to trap the smoke inside. Leave one end open—this is where you'll attach it to your smoke source.
1Start with Cool Smoke
Your smoke should be thick and cool—not hot. If you can't hold your hand in the smoke for 10 seconds, it's too hot. Hot smoke will shrink and stiffen your hide. Add more punky wood to cool it down.
2Smoke the First Side
Place your hide bag over the smoke source with the flesh side facing in (the side you scraped). Let it smoke for 30-60 minutes, or until the hide turns a golden tan color. Check it every 15 minutes to make sure it's not getting too hot.
3Flip and Smoke the Other Side
Turn the hide inside-out so the grain side (hair side) is now facing the smoke. Smoke for another 30-60 minutes. Some tanners only smoke the flesh side, but smoking both sides gives better waterproofing.
4Check Your Color
The hide should be an even golden-tan to medium brown color. If you see white or pale spots, those areas didn't get enough smoke. You can spot-smoke them or do another full round.
5Let It Rest
After smoking, let the hide air out for a few hours. The smoke smell will mellow over time. Some people like a heavy smoke scent; others prefer lighter. You can always smoke it more, but you can't un-smoke it.
Common Smoking Mistakes
Smoke Too Hot
This will shrink and stiffen your hide. Always test with your hand—if it's too hot to hold there, it's too hot for your hide.
Not Enough Smoke Time
Rushing the process means the smoke won't penetrate deeply enough. The hide might look tan but will still stiffen when wet.
Uneven Smoking
White or pale patches mean those areas didn't get enough smoke. Make sure smoke circulates evenly throughout the hide bag.
Using Fresh Wood
Green wood burns too hot and doesn't produce the right kind of smoke. Stick with punky, rotten wood.
Testing Your Smoke Job
Want to know if you smoked it enough? Here's the ultimate test:
The Water Test
- 1.Cut a small test piece from the edge of your hide (2x2 inches).
- 2.Soak it in water for 10 minutes.
- 3.Wring it out and let it dry naturally.
- 4.If it dries soft, you're good! If it dries stiff, you need more smoke.
A properly smoked hide will dry soft after washing. That's the magic of smoke.
Color Variations
Different woods and smoking times create different colors:
Light Tan
30-45 minutes of light smoke. Subtle color, mild scent. Good for garments worn close to skin.
Medium Brown
60-90 minutes. Classic buckskin color. Best balance of waterproofing and appearance.
Dark Brown
90+ minutes of heavy smoke. Maximum waterproofing, strong scent. Great for outdoor gear.
Troubleshooting
Hide Still Stiffens When Wet
Problem: Not enough smoke penetration.
Solution: Smoke it again for longer. Make sure the smoke is thick and cool, and give it more time.
Uneven Color
Problem: Smoke didn't reach all areas evenly.
Solution: Check for wrinkles or folds in your hide bag. Smooth it out and spot-smoke the pale areas.
Hide Shrank or Stiffened During Smoking
Problem: Smoke was too hot.
Solution: Dampen the hide slightly and re-break it soft. Next time, use cooler smoke and check temperature frequently.
Too Much Smoke Smell
Problem: Over-smoked or used resinous wood.
Solution: Air it out for several days. The smell will mellow. Avoid pine and cedar next time.
The Final Step
Smoking is where all your hard work comes together. It's the moment when soft, white buckskin transforms into durable, washable leather that will last for years. The smoke seals the fibers, locks in the softness, and gives the hide its soul.
There's something deeply satisfying about pulling a hide off the smoke and seeing that rich, even color. You can smell the wood, feel the warmth still in the leather, and know that you've completed a process that humans have been doing for thousands of years.
Take your time with this step. Don't rush it. The smoke that seals your hide also seals your connection to this ancient craft.
Continue Your Journey
Brain Tanning Guide
Learn the complete brain tanning process from start to finish.
Breaking & Softening
Master the techniques for breaking hides soft before smoking.
Troubleshooting Guide
Solutions for common tanning problems and challenges.
More Articles
Explore more stories and techniques from the tannery.